Showing posts with label Strategi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Strategi. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Posisi RI dalam The New7Sisters *)*)


Apa kehebatan Malaysia dengan Petronas-nya sehingga dengan cadangan migas yang kalah jauh dari Indonesia masuk dalam The New7Sisters

Berbeda dengan pemilihan Komodo sebagai "The New7Wonders" yang kontroversial, komite pemilihan "The New7Sisters" (N7S), yang dikoordinasi oleh majalah Financial Times, tidak menggunakan model voting melalui SMS terbanyak. Penilaian "keajaiban" lebih menitikberatkan pada kriteria penguasaan cadangan migas, tingkat produksi, dan pengembangan usaha dari perusahaan minyak kelas dunia yang telah berhasil menggeser posisi kehormatan "The Old7Sisters".

Komite berhasil memilih kelompok The New7Sisters, yang terdiri atas Saudi Aramco, Gazprom (Rusia), CNPC (Cina), NIOC (Iran), PDVSA (Venezuela), Petrobras (Brasil), dan Petronas (Malaysia). Tujuh perusahaan minyak nasional itu menguasai lebih dari sepertiga cadangan serta produksi minyak dan gas dunia. Bandingkan dengan seven sisters yang lama (BP, Shell, dan lainnya), yang kini hanya mengontrol 3 persen cadangan dan 10 persen produksi migas dunia. Sayang, perusahaan negara "wakil" dari Indonesia telah tereliminasi sejak babak awal, diyakini karena dukungan "sponsor" yang setengah hati. Posisi perusahaan minyak nasional berhasil menjadi perusahaan kelas dunia terutama karena adanya dukungan dan perlakuan khusus dari negara sebagai sponsor utama.

Republik Indonesia sebagai "sponsor" perusahaan minyak nasional boleh meniru semangat, idealisme, dan kesungguhan negara-negara yang telah mengantar perusahaan minyak nasionalnya menjadi world class company dalam waktu relatif singkat, terlepas dari kontroversi politik negaranya. Sebagai sumber inspirasi bagi RI, di bawah ini ada kisah dua negara berkembang yang sukses mengantar perusahaan minyak nasionalnya masuk N7S dengan dua orientasi yang berbeda. Dua negara itu adalah Venezuela, yang mewakili "garis keras" dengan orientasi sumber daya dalam negeri, dan Malaysia, yang mewakili "garis moderat" dengan orientasi luar negeri karena sumber daya di dalam negeri relatif kecil.

Disadari banyak kelemahan dan karut-marut di wajah perusahaan minyak nasional, tapi jasa mereka bagi bangsa dan negara tidak terbilang, terutama pada saat negara dalam keadaan krisis. Pada 1970-an, migas selalu menjadi lokomotif penarik gerbong ekonomi Indonesia melalui kontribusi anggaran pendapatan dan belanja negara lebih dari 70 persen. Pada krisis ekonomi 1997-1998, migas menjadi penyelamat ekonomi Indonesia. Kini, walaupun Indonesia sudah menjadi nett oil importer dan porsi penerimaan migas di APBN tinggal sekitar 20 persen, keberadaan sektor migas masih sangat dibutuhkan oleh rakyat Indonesia. Pada masa prihatin, dibutuhkan keberadaan perusahaan minyak nasional yang lebih kuat. Momen revisi Undang-Undang Migas adalah saat yang tepat bagi RI untuk mulai menunjukkan keberpihakan kepada perusahaan minyak nasional.

Melawan hegemoni sebagian publik mengira bahwa cadangan minyak terbesar di dunia dikuasai Arab Saudi. Namun dua bulan yang lalu OPEC mengumumkan kini Venezuela yang menguasai cadangan minyak terbesar di dunia, yaitu 296,5 miliar barel (bandingkan dengan cadangan Indonesia sebesar 3,9 miliar barel). Perusahaan minyak nasional Venezuela, PDVSA, salah satu anggota N7S, menjadi perusahaan minyak terbesar keempat di dunia berdasarkan data cadangan terbukti, produksi, pengilangan, dan penjualan.

Sejatinya, sejak 1990-an, Venezuela, melalui PDVSA, telah membuka diri untuk bekerja sama dengan perusahaan minyak asing melalui joint ventures dan operating agreements. Namun, melihat perkembangan perusahaan minyak nasional yang kurang menggembirakan, pada Februari 2007 Presiden Chavez mendeklarasikan aturan baru, yaitu nasionalisasi" (lebih tepat disebut "renegosiasi"), bagi semua perusahaan minyak asing di Venezuela.

Dalam aturan yang berlaku mulai 1 Mei 2007 itu, Chavez "mengimbau" semua perusahaan asing untuk melakukan negosiasi ulang atas seluruh kontrak di mana mensyaratkan perusahaan nasional PDVSA menguasai saham minimal 60 persen, termasuk kontrak ExxonMobil, ChevronTexaco, Statoil, ConocoPhillips, BP, dan lainnya. Mempertimbangkan cadangan yang berlimpah, akhirnya semua perusahaan minyak asing menerima ketentuan baru tersebut. Hanya dua perusahaan yang mengajukan permohonan banding ke pengadilan, yaitu ExxonMobil dan ConocoPhillips, tapi akhirnya mereka juga menyerah.

Presiden Chavez mengontrol langsung aturan baru itu demi mengangkat peran perusahaan minyak nasional PDVSA. Sayang, kini Chavez dalam keadaan sakit serius. Diperkirakan Washington tidak tinggal diam. Perusahaan minyak asing menunggu dengan harap-harap cemas datangnya momen perubahan yang lebih menguntungkan bagi bisnis dan negara asal mereka, terutama Amerika Serikat.

Nasionalisme Mahathir
Berjayanya Petronas, yang didirikan pada 1974, tidak lepas dari jasa pemerintah Malaysia, terutama tekad Perdana Menteri Mahathir Mohamad mengusung Petronas mulai dalam negeri hingga jauh ke mancanegara sehingga layak terpilih masuk kelompok N7S, kendati sumber daya migas di dalam negeri relatif sangat kecil.

Salah satu strategi unik Mahathir dalam membesarkan perusahaan minyak nasional adalah memanfaatkan sentimen keagamaan untuk mendekati negara-negara Islam yang tergabung dalam OKI di Timur Tengah dan Afrika. Pendekatan gaya primordial ini mendapat sambutan luar biasa, sehingga Petronas memperoleh banyak konsesi migas dalam waktu singkat. Walaupun cara ini banyak ditentang oleh negara-negara Barat, Mahathir tidak peduli dan tetap konsisten. Bandingkan dengan Indonesia. Kendati memiliki penduduk Islam terbesar di dunia, RI tidak cukup memiliki keberanian untuk mengangkat perusahaan minyak nasional ke pentas dunia dengan gaya Mahathir.

Strategi unik lain yang ditempuh adalah mendekati negara-negara yang dianggap "bermasalah", baik oleh negara-negara Barat, terutama Amerika, maupun oleh organisasi kemanusiaan. Negara-negara "bermasalah" itu contohnya Iran, Sudan, dan Myanmar. Malaysia disambut dengan tangan terbuka dan Petronas berhasil menguasai beberapa konsesi di negara-negara "bermasalah" tersebut. Kini Petronas merambah konsesi migas di mancanegara di lebih dari 30 negara (termasuk Blok East Natuna di Indonesia), yang berhasil masuk Global 500 (peringkat ke-86) dengan keuntungan bersih pada 2010 mencapai US$ 17,48 miliar.

Bagaimana dengan RI?
Rakyat menunggu tampilnya pemimpin Indonesia yang benar-benar mempunyai political will untuk membesarkan perusahaan minyak nasional di dalam dan luar negeri. Sayang bila Menteri Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral yang baru dan wakilnya bangga hanya menjadi safe players dan membiarkan perusahaan negara berjuang sendirian menjadi flag carrier Indonesia.

Kini saatnya RI mengangkat perusahaan minyak nasional agar dapat memberikan kontribusi yang lebih besar bagi bangsa dan negara. Pelajaran berharga dari tokoh-tokoh seperti Chavez dan Mahathir serta kelompok New7Sisters dapat dikaji, terutama idealisme dan political will mereka untuk membesarkan perusahaan minyak nasional.

Indonesia tidak harus mengekor gaya Chavez atau Mahathir. Indonesia harus mencari cara yang lebih elegan disesuaikan dengan tingkat sumber daya dan risiko, baik geopolitik maupun ekonomi, serta iklim investasi. Indonesia dapat mulai menunjukkan keberpihakan dengan menyerahkan pengelolaan lapangan migas yang habis masa kontraknya kepada perusahaan minyak nasional.

Jangan takut memberikan hak istimewa kepada perusahaan milik negara, seperti layaknya negara berdaulat RI berkewajiban mengantarkannya menjadi world class company tanpa harus terlalu khawatir dibayangi ancaman "kekuatan" di belakang perusahaan minyak asing. Sepanjang tingkat keuntungan mereka di Indonesia wajar dan berkeadilan, diyakini mereka tidak akan lari meninggalkan Indonesia.

Salah satu jalan pintas mengangkat industri migas nasional adalah membesarkan perusahaan minyak nasional sekaligus mendekatkan posisi flag carrier RI menuju The New 7 Sisters.


*) Disarikan dari tulisan Eddy Purwanto, Mantan Deputi BP Migas

Thursday, September 1, 2011

Countdown to D-Day

Our real problem, then, is not our strength today; it is rather the vital necessity of action today to ensure our strength tomorrow.
Dwight D. Eisenhower


The Normandy landings, codenamed Operation Neptune, were the landing operations of the Allied invasion of Normandy, in Operation Overlord, during World War II. The landings commenced on Tuesday, 6 June 1944 (D-Day), beginning at 6:30 AM British Double Summer Time (GMT+2). In planning, D-Day was the term used for the day of actual landing, which was dependent on final approval.


The landings were conducted in two phases: an airborne assault landing of 24,000 British, American, Canadian and Free French airborne troops shortly after midnight, and an amphibious landing of Allied infantry and armoured divisions on the coast of France starting at 6:30 AM. There were also decoy operations under the codenames Operation Glimmer and Operation Taxable to distract the German forces from the real landing areas.[4]

The operation, planned by a team under Lieutenant-General Frederick Morgan, was the largest amphibious invasion in world history and was executed by land, sea and air elements under direct British command with over 160,000[5] troops landing on 6 June 1944. 195,700[6] Allied naval and merchant navy personnel in over 5,000[5] ships were involved. The invasion required the transport of soldiers and material from the United Kingdom by troop-laden aircraft and ships, the assault landings, air support, naval interdiction of the English Channel and naval fire-support. The landings took place along a 50-mile (80 km) stretch of the Normandy coast divided into five sectors: Utah, Omaha, Gold, Juno and Sword.

Operations

The Allied invasion was detailed in several overlapping operational plans according to the D-Day museum:

"The armed forces used codenames to refer to the planning and execution of specific military operations. Operation Overlord was the codename for the Allied invasion of northwest Europe. The assault phase of Operation Overlord was known as Operation Neptune. Operation Neptune began on D-Day (June 6, 1944) and ended on 30 June 1944. By this time, the Allies had established a firm foothold in Normandy. Operation Overlord also began on D-Day, and continued until Allied forces crossed the River Seine on 19 August 1944."

Just prior to the invasion, General Eisenhower transmitted a now-historic message to all members of the Allied Expeditionary Force. It read, in part, "You are about to embark upon the great crusade, toward which we have striven these many months."[7] In his pocket was a statement, never used, to be read in case the invasion failed.

Only a few days in each month were suitable for launching the operation: a day near the full Moon was needed both for illumination during the hours of darkness and for the spring tide, the former to illuminate navigational landmarks for the crews of aircraft, gliders and landing craft, and the latter to provide the deepest possible water to help safe navigation over defensive obstacles placed by the Germans in the surf on the seaward approaches to the beaches. A full moon occurred on June 6. Allied Expeditionary Force Supreme Commander Dwight D. Eisenhower had tentatively selected 5 June as the date for the assault. The weather was fine during most of May, but deteriorated in early June. On 4 June, conditions were clearly unsuitable for a landing; wind and high seas would make it impossible to launch landing craft from larger ships at sea, and low clouds would prevent aircraft finding their targets. The Allied troop convoys already at sea were forced to take shelter in bays and inlets on the south coast of Britain for the night.

It seemed possible that everything would have to be cancelled and the troops returned to their embarkation camps (which would be almost impossible, as the enormous movement of follow-up formations into them was already proceeding). The next full moon period would be nearly a month away. At a vital meeting on 5 June, Eisenhower's chief meteorologist (Group Captain J.M. Stagg) forecast a brief improvement for 6 June. Commander of all land forces for the invasion General Bernard Montgomery and Eisenhower's Chief of Staff General Walter Bedell Smith wished to proceed with the invasion. Commander of the Allied Air Forces Air Chief Marshal Leigh Mallory was doubtful, but the Allied Naval supremo Admiral Bertram Ramsay believed that conditions would be marginally favourable. On the strength of Stagg's forecast, Eisenhower ordered the invasion to proceed. As a result, prevailing overcast skies limited Allied air support, and no serious damage was done to the beach defences on Omaha and Juno.[9]

The Germans meanwhile took comfort from the existing poor conditions, which were worse over Northern France than over the Channel itself, and believed no invasion would be possible for several days. Some troops stood down, and many senior officers were away for the weekend. Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, for example, took a few days' leave to celebrate his wife's birthday.[10] While dozens of division, regimental, and battalion commanders were away from their posts at war games, the Allied forces were attacking.[citation needed]
Allied order of battle
D-day assault routes into Normandy

The order of battle for the landings was approximately as follows, east to west:
[edit] British Second Army 6th Airborne Division Commanded by Major-General R.N. Gale was delivered by parachute and glider to the east of the River Orne to protect the left flank. The division contained 7,900 men, including one Canadian battalion.[11]

Sword Beach

1st Special Service Brigade comprising No. 3, No. 4, No. 6 and No. 45 (RM) Commandos landed at Ouistreham in Queen Red sector (leftmost). No.4 Commando were augmented by 1 and 8 Troop (both French) of No. 10 (Inter Allied) Commando.
I Corps, 3rd Infantry Division and the 27th Armoured Brigade from Ouistreham to Lion-sur-Mer.
No. 41 (RM) Commando (part of 4th Special Service Brigade) landed on the far West of Sword Beach.[12]

Paratrooper about to jump into combat on D-Day, on June 6, 1944

Juno Beach

3rd Canadian Infantry Division, 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade and No.48 (RM) Commando from Saint-Aubin-sur-Mer to Courseulles-sur-Mer.[11]
No. 46 (RM) Commando (part of 4th Special Service Brigade) at Juno to scale the cliffs on the left side of the Orne River estuary and destroy a battery. (Battery fire proved negligible so No.46 were kept off-shore as a floating reserve and landed on D+1).

Assault troops of the 3rd battalion 16th RCT, from the first two waves, shelter under the chalk cliffs, Omaha Beach.

Gold Beach

XXX Corps, 50th (Northumbrian) Infantry Division and 8th Armoured Brigade, consisting of 25,000.[13] from Courseulles to Arromanches.
No. 47 (RM) Commando (part of 4th Special Service Brigade) on the West flank of Gold beach.

79th Armoured Division operated specialist armour ("Hobart's Funnies") for mine-clearing, recovery and assault tasks. These were distributed around the Anglo-Canadian beaches.

Overall, the 2nd Army contingent consisted of 83,115 troops (61,715 of them British).[11] In addition to the British and Canadian combat units, eight Australian officers were attached to the British forces as observers.[14] The nominally British air and naval support units included a large number of crew from Allied nations, including several RAF squadrons manned almost exclusively by foreign air-crew.
[edit] U.S. First Army

Omaha Beach

V Corps, 1st Infantry Division and 29th Infantry Division making up 34,250 troops from Sainte-Honorine-des-Pertes to Vierville-sur-Mer.[11][15]
2nd and 5th Ranger Battalions at Pointe du Hoc (The 5th BN and A, B, C Co 2nd BN diverted to Omaha).[15]

Utah Beach

VII Corps, 4th Infantry Division and the 359th RCT of the 90th Infantry Division comprising 23,250 men landing, around Pouppeville and La Madeleine.[15]

101st Airborne Division by parachute around Vierville to support Utah Beach landings.[15]
82nd Airborne Division by parachute around Sainte-Mère-Église, protecting the right flank. They had originally been tasked with dropping further west, in the middle part of the Cotentin, allowing the sea-landing forces to their east easier access across the peninsula, and preventing the Germans from reinforcing the north part of the peninsula. The plans were later changed to move them much closer to the beachhead, as at the last minute the German 91st Air Landing Division was determined to be in the area.[15][16]

In total, the First Army contingent totalled approximately 73,000 men, including 15,600 from the airborne divisions.[11]
[edit] German order of battle

The military forces at the disposal of Nazi Germany reached its numerical peak during 1944. By D-Day, 157 German divisions were stationed in the Soviet Union, 6 in Finland, 12 in Norway, 6 in Denmark, 9 in Germany, 21 in the Balkans, 26 in Italy and 59 in France, Belgium and the Netherlands.[17] However, these statistics are somewhat misleading since a significant number of the divisions in the east were depleted due to intensity of fighting; German records indicate that the average personnel complement was at about 50% in the spring of 1944.[18]
[edit] German defences

The German defences used an interlocking firing style, so they could protect areas that were receiving heavy fire. They had large bunkers, sometimes intricate concrete ones containing machine guns and large-calibre weapons. Their defence also integrated the cliffs and hills overlooking the beaches. The defences were all built and refined over a four year period.
[edit] Atlantic Wall
Main articles: Atlantic Wall and English Channel
A map of the Atlantic Wall, shown in green.
German Reich, allies and occupied zones
Allies

The Germans' first line of defence was the English Channel, a crossing which had confounded the Spanish Armada and Napoleon Bonaparte's Navy. Compounding the invasion efforts was the extensive Atlantic Wall, ordered by Hitler in his Directive 51. Believing that any forthcoming landings would be timed for high tide, Rommel had the entire wall fortified with tank top turrets and extensive barbed wire, and laid hundreds of thousands of mines to deter landing craft. The Allies chose to attack close to the sector boundary between the 7th and 15th German armies, on the extreme eastern flank of the former, to maximize the possible confusion of command responsibility during German reaction. The landings sector which was attacked was occupied by four German divisions.
[edit] Divisional areas

716th Infantry Division (Static) defended the Eastern end of the landing zones, including most of the British and Canadian beaches. This division, as well as the 709th, included Germans who were not considered fit for active duty on the Eastern Front, usually for medical reasons, and soldiers of various other nationalities (from conquered countries, often drafted by force) and former Soviet prisoners-of-war who had agreed to fight for the Germans rather than endure the harsh conditions of German POW camps (among them so called hiwis). These "volunteers" were concentrated in "Ost-Bataillone" (East Battalions) that were of dubious loyalty.
352nd Infantry Division was a well-trained and equipped formation defending the area between approximately Bayeux and Carentan, including Omaha beach. The division had been formed in November 1943 with the help of cadres from the disbanded 321st Division, which had been destroyed in the Soviet Union that same year. The 352nd had a number of troops who had seen action on the eastern front. Therefore, the 352nd already had significant fighting experience at holding a defensive position. The division was stationed at Omaha Beach, where by far the heaviest casualties of the invasion were suffered by the landing U.S. forces.
91st Air Landing Division (Luftlande–air transported) (Generalmajor Wilhelm Falley), comprising the 1057th Infantry Regiment and 1058th Infantry Regiment. This was a regular infantry division, trained, and equipped to be transported by air (i.e. transportable artillery, few heavy support weapons) located in the interior of the Cotentin Peninsula, including the drop zones of the American parachute landings. The attached 6th Parachute Regiment (Oberstleutnant Friedrich August Freiherr von der Heydte) had been rebuilt as a part of the 2nd Parachute Division stationed in Brittany.
709th Infantry Division (Static) (Generalleutnant Karl-Wilhelm von Schlieben), comprising the 729th Infantry Regiment, 739th Infantry Regiment (both with four battalions, but the 729th 4th and the 739th 1st and 4th being Ost, these two regiments had no regimental support companies either), and 919th Infantry Regiment. This coastal defence division protected the eastern, and northern (including Cherbourg) coast of the Cotentin Peninsula, including the Utah beach landing zone. Like the 716th, this division comprised a number of "Ost" units who were provided with German leadership to manage them.

Other divisions occupied the areas around the landing zones, including:

243rd Infantry Division (Static) (Generalleutnant Heinz Hellmich), comprising the 920th Infantry Regiment (two battalions), 921st Infantry Regiment, and 922nd Infantry Regiment. This coastal defence division protected the western coast of the Cotentin Peninsula.
711th Infantry Division (Static), comprising the 731th Infantry Regiment, and 744th Infantry Regiment. This division defended the western part of the Pays de Caux.
30th Mobile Brigade (Oberstleutnant Freiherr von und zu Aufsess), comprising three bicycle battalions.

[edit] Armoured reserves

Rommel's defensive measures were also frustrated by a dispute over armoured doctrine. In addition to his two army groups, von Rundstedt also commanded the headquarters of Panzer Group West under General Leo Geyr von Schweppenburg (usually referred to as von Geyr). This formation was nominally an administrative HQ for von Rundstedt's armoured and mobile formations, but it was later to be renamed Fifth Panzer Army and brought into the line in Normandy. Von Geyr and Rommel disagreed over the deployment and use of the vital Panzer divisions.

Rommel recognised that the Allies would possess air superiority and would be able to harass his movements from the air. He therefore proposed that the armoured formations be deployed close to the invasion beaches. In his words, it was better to have one Panzer division facing the invaders on the first day, than three Panzer divisions three days later when the Allies would already have established a firm beachhead. Von Geyr argued for the standard doctrine that the Panzer formations should be concentrated in a central position around Paris and Rouen, and deployed en masse against the main Allied beachhead when this had been identified.

The argument was eventually brought before Hitler for arbitration. He characteristically imposed an unworkable compromise solution. Only three Panzer divisions were given to Rommel, too few to cover all the threatened sectors. The remainder, nominally under Von Geyr's control, were actually designated as being in "OKW Reserve". Only three of these were deployed close enough to intervene immediately against any invasion of Northern France, the other four were dispersed in southern France and the Netherlands. Hitler reserved to himself the authority to move the divisions in OKW Reserve, or commit them to action. On 6 June, many Panzer division commanders were unable to move because Hitler had not given the necessary authorization, and his staff refused to wake him upon news of the invasion.

The 21st Panzer Division (Generalmajor Edgar Feuchtinger) was deployed near Caen as a mobile striking force as part of the Army Group B reserve. However, Rommel placed it so close to the coastal defences that, under standing orders in case of invasion, several of its infantry and anti-aircraft units would come under the orders of the fortress divisions on the coast, reducing the effective strength of the division.

The other mechanized divisions capable of intervening in Normandy were retained under the direct control of the German Armed Forces HQ (OKW) and were initially denied to Rommel.
[edit] Coordination with the French Resistance

The various factions and circuits of the French Resistance were included in the plan for Overlord. Through a London-based headquarters which supposedly embraced all resistance groups, État-major des Forces Françaises de l'Intérieur (EMFFI), the British Special Operations Executive orchestrated a massive campaign of sabotage tasking the various Groups with attacking railway lines, ambushing roads, or destroying telephone exchanges or electrical substations. The resistance was alerted to carry out these tasks by means of the messages personnels, transmitted by the BBC in its French service from London. Several hundred of these were regularly transmitted, masking the few of them that were really significant.
Francs-tireurs and Allied paratroopers reporting on the situation during the Battle of Normandy in 1944.

Among the stream of apparently meaningless messages broadcast by the BBC at 21:00 CET on 5 June were coded instructions such as Les carottes sont cuites ("The carrots are cooked") and Les dés sont jetés ("The dice have been thrown").[19]

One famous pair of these messages is often mistakenly stated to be a general call to arms by the Resistance. A few days before D-Day, the (slightly misquoted) first line of Verlaine's poem, Chanson d'Automne, was transmitted. "Les sanglots longs des violons de l'automne"[20][21] (Long sobs of autumn violins) alerted the resistance fighters of the Ventriloquist network in the Orléans region to attack rail targets within the next few days. The second line, "Bercent mon coeur d'une langueur monotone" ("soothe my heart with a monotonous languor"), transmitted late on 5 June, meant that the attack was to be mounted immediately.

Josef Götz, the head of the signals section of the German intelligence service (the SD) in Paris, had discovered the meaning of the second line of Verlaine's poem, and no fewer than fourteen other executive orders they heard late on 5 June. His section rightly interpreted them to mean that an invasion was imminent or underway, and they alerted their superiors and all Army commanders in France. However, they had issued a similar warning a month before, when the Allies had begun invasion preparations and alerted the Resistance, but then stood down because of a forecast of bad weather. The SD having given this false alarm, their genuine alarm was ignored or treated as merely routine. Fifteenth Army HQ passed the information on to its units; Seventh Army ignored it.[21]

In addition to the tasks given to the Resistance as part of the invasion effort, the Special Operations Executive planned to reinforce the Resistance with three-man liaison parties, under Operation Jedburgh. The Jedburgh parties would coordinate and arrange supply drops to the Maquis groups in the German rear areas. Also operating far behind German lines and frequently working closely with the Resistance, although not under SOE, were larger parties from the British, French and Belgian units of the Special Air Service brigade.
[edit] Naval activity
Large landing craft convoy crosses the English Channel on 6 June 1944.

The Invasion Fleet was drawn from eight different navies, comprising 6,939 vessels: 1,213 warships, 4,126 transport vessels (landing ships and landing craft), and 736 ancillary craft and 864 merchant vessels.[11]

The overall commander of the Allied Naval Expeditionary Force, providing close protection and bombardment at the beaches, was Admiral Sir Bertram Ramsay who had been responsible for the planning of the invasion of North Africa in 1942 and one of the two fleets carrying troops for the invasion of Sicily in the following year. The Allied Naval Expeditionary Force was divided into two Naval Task Forces: Western (Rear-Admiral Alan G Kirk) and Eastern (Rear-Admiral Sir Philip Vian – another veteran of the Italian landings).

The warships provided cover for the transports against any enemy surface warships, submarines or aerial attack, and supported the landings with shore bombardment. These ships included the Allied Task Force "O". A small part of the naval operation was Operation Gambit, when British midget submarines supplied navigation beacons to guide landing craft.
[edit] Naval screen

An important part of Neptune was the isolation of the invasion routes and beaches from any intervention by the German Navy – the Kriegsmarine. The responsibility for this was assigned to the Royal Navy's Home Fleet. There were two principal perceived German naval threats. The first was surface attack by German capital ships from anchorages in Scandinavia and the Baltic Sea. This did not materialise since, by mid-1944, the battleships were damaged, the cruisers were used for training and the Kriegsmarine's fuel allocation had been cut by a third. In any case,as the worlds largest navy the Royal Navy had strong forces available to repel any attempts, and the Kiel Canal area was mined (Operation Bravado)[22] as a precaution.

The second perceived major threat was that of U-boats transferred from the Atlantic. Air surveillance from three escort carriers and RAF Coastal Command maintained a cordon well west of Land's End. Few U-boats were spotted, and most of the escort groups were moved nearer to the landings.

Further efforts were made to seal the Western Approaches against German naval forces from Brittany and the Bay of Biscay. Minefields were laid (Operation Maple) to force enemy ships away from air protection where they could be attacked by Allied destroyer flotillas. Again, enemy activity was minor, but on 4 July four German destroyers were either sunk or forced back to Brest.

The Straits of Dover were closed by minefields, naval and air patrols, radar, and effective bombing raids on enemy ports. Local German naval forces were small but could be reinforced from the Baltic. Their efforts, however, were concentrated on protecting the Pas de Calais against expected landings there, and no attempt was made to force the blockade.

The screening operation destroyed few German ships, but the objective was achieved. There were no U-boat attacks against Allied shipping and few attempts by surface ships.
[edit] Bombardment
The view from HMS Kelvin showing the wide variety of vessels deployed.

Warships provided supporting fire for the land forces. During Neptune, it was given a high importance, using ships from battleships to destroyers and landing craft. For example, the Canadians at Juno beach had fire support many times greater than they had had for the Dieppe Raid in 1942. The old battleships HMS Ramillies and Warspite and the monitor HMS Roberts were used to suppress shore batteries east of the Orne; cruisers targeted shore batteries at Ver-sur-Mer and Moulineaux; eleven destroyers for local fire support. In addition, there were modified landing-craft: eight "Landing Craft Gun", each with two 4.7-inch guns; four "Landing Craft Support" with automatic cannon; eight Landing Craft Tank (Rocket), each with a single salvo of 1,100 5-inch rockets; eight Landing Craft Assault (Hedgerow), each with twenty-four bombs intended to detonate beach mines prematurely. Twenty-four Landing Craft Tank carried Priest self-propelled howitzers which also fired while they were on the run-in to the beach. Similar arrangements existed at other beaches.

Fire support went beyond the suppression of shore defences overlooking landing beaches and was also used to break up enemy concentrations as the troops moved inland. This was particularly noted in German reports: Field-Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt reported that:

... The enemy had deployed very strong Naval forces off the shores of the bridgehead. These can be used as quickly mobile, constantly available artillery, at points where they are necessary as defence against our attacks or as support for enemy attacks. During the day their fire is skilfully directed by . . . plane observers, and by advanced ground fire spotters. Because of the high rapid-fire capacity of Naval guns they play an important part in the battle within their range. The movement of tanks by day, in open country, within the range of these naval guns is hardly possible.[23]

[edit] Naval losses

The only naval contact during D-Day occurred when four German torpedo boats reached the Eastern Task Force late in the afternoon and launched eighteen torpedoes, sinking the Norwegian destroyer Svenner off Sword beach but missing the battleships HMS Warspite and HMS Ramillies. After firing, the German vessels turned away and fled east into a smoke screen. Thanks to ULTRA, the Allies knew where the German channels through their own minefields were and the only Allied losses to mines were the USS Corry off of Utah; USS PC-1261, a 173-foot patrol craft; three LCTs; and two LCIs.[24]
[edit] The landings
Twelfth United States Army Group situation map for 2400 hours, 6 June 1944.
[edit] Airborne operations

The success of the amphibious landings depended on the establishment of a secure lodgement from which to expand the beachhead to allow the build up of a well-supplied force capable of breaking out. The amphibious forces were especially vulnerable to strong enemy counter-attacks before the build up of sufficient forces in the beachhead could be accomplished. To slow or eliminate the enemy's ability to organize and launch counter-attacks during this critical period, airborne operations were used to seize key objectives, such as bridges, road crossings, and terrain features, particularly on the eastern and western flanks of the landing areas. The airborne landings some distance behind the beaches were also intended to ease the egress of the amphibious forces off the beaches, and in some cases to neutralize German coastal defence batteries and more quickly expand the area of the beachhead. The U.S. 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions were assigned to objectives west of Utah Beach. The British 6th Airborne Division was assigned to similar objectives on the eastern flank. 530 Free French paratroopers from the British Special Air Service Brigade, were assigned to objectives in Brittany from 5 June to August.[25][26] (Operation Dingson, Operation Samwest).
[edit] British airborne landings
Main article: Operation Tonga

The first Allied action of D-Day was Operation Deadstick a glider assault at 00:16 on the bridges over the Caen canal and the River Orne. These were the only crossings of the river and canal north of Caen around 7 kilometres (4.5 mi) from the coast, near Bénouville and Ranville. For the Germans, the crossing provided the only route for a flanking attack on the beaches from the east. For the Allies, the crossing also was vital for any attack on Caen from the east.
Destroyed British glider used during the landings.

The tactical objectives of the British 6th Airborne Division were (a) to capture intact the bridges of the Bénouville-Ranville crossing, (b) to defend the crossing against the inevitable armoured counter-attacks, (c) to destroy German artillery at the Merville battery, which threatened Sword Beach, and (d) to destroy five bridges over the Dives River to further restrict movement of ground forces from the east.

Airborne troops, mostly paratroopers of the 3rd and 5th Parachute Brigades, including the 1st Canadian Parachute Battalion, began landing after midnight, 6 June and immediately encountered elements of the German 716th Infantry Division. At dawn, the Battle Group von Luck of the 21st Panzer Division counterattacked from the south on both sides of the Orne River. By this time the paratroopers had established a defensive perimeter surrounding the bridgehead. Casualties were heavy on both sides, but the airborne troops held. Shortly after noon, they were reinforced by commandos of the 1st Special Service Brigade. By the end of D-Day, reinforced by Operation Mallard the 6th Airborne had accomplished all of its objectives. For several days, both British and German forces took heavy casualties as they struggled for positions around the Orne bridgehead. For example, the German 346th Infantry Division broke through the eastern edge of the defensive line on 10 June. Finally, British paratroopers overwhelmed entrenched panzergrenadiers in the Battle of Breville on 12 June. The Germans did not seriously threaten the bridgehead again. 6th Airborne remained on the line until it was evacuated in early September.
[edit] American airborne landings
Main article: American airborne landings in Normandy
U.S. troops of the 3rd Armored Division examine a knocked out German StuG III with a dead German crewman slumped over gun barrel.

The U.S. 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions, numbering 13,000 paratroopers delivered by 12 troop carrier groups of the IX Troop Carrier Command, were less fortunate in completing their main objectives. To achieve surprise, the drops were routed to approach Normandy from the west. Numerous factors affected their performance, the primary of which was the decision to make a massive parachute drop at night (a tactic not used again for the rest of the war). As a result, 45% of units were widely scattered and unable to rally. Efforts of the early wave of pathfinder teams to mark the landing zones were largely ineffective, and the Rebecca/Eureka transponding radar beacons used to guide in the waves of C-47 Skytrains to the drop zones were the main component of a flawed system.

Three regiments of 101st Airborne paratroopers were dropped first, between 00:48 and 01:40, followed by the 82nd Airborne's drops between 01:51 and 02:42. Each operation involved approximately 400 C-47 aircraft. Two pre-dawn glider landings brought in anti-tank guns and support troops for each division. On the evening of D-Day two additional glider landings brought in two battalions of artillery and 24 howitzers to the 82nd Airborne. Additional glider operations on 7 June delivered the 325th Glider Infantry Regiment to the 82nd Airborne, and two large supply parachute drops that date were ineffective.

After 24 hours, only 2,500 troops of the 101st and 2,000 of the 82nd were under the control of their divisions, approximating a third of the force dropped. The dispersal of the American airborne troops, however, had the effect of confusing the Germans and fragmenting their response. In addition, the Germans' defensive flooding, in the early stages, also helped to protect the Americans' southern flank.

Paratroopers continued to roam and fight behind enemy lines for days. Many consolidated into small groups, rallied with NCOs or junior officers, and usually were a hodgepodge of men from different companies, battalions, regiments, or even divisions. The 82nd occupied the town of Sainte-Mère-Église early in the morning of 6 June, giving it the claim of the first town liberated in the invasion.
[edit] Sword Beach
Main article: Sword Beach
British troops take cover after landing on Sword Beach.

The assault on Sword Beach began at about 03:00 with an aerial bombardment of the German coastal defences and artillery sites. The naval bombardment began a few hours later. At 07:30, the first units reached the beach. These were the DD tanks of 13th/18th Hussars followed closely by the infantry of 8th Brigade.

On Sword Beach, the regular British infantry came ashore with light casualties. They had advanced about 8 kilometres (5 mi) by the end of the day but failed to make some of the deliberately ambitious targets set by Montgomery. In particular, Caen, a major objective, was still in German hands by the end of D-Day, and would remain so until mid July (central urban area cleared 8–9 July, suburbs fully cleared by 20 July in Operation Atlantic) Battle for Caen.

1st Special Service Brigade, under the command of Brigadier The Lord Lovat DSO, MC, went ashore in the second wave led by No.4 Commando with the two French Troops first, as agreed amongst themselves. The 1st Special Service Brigade's landing is famous for having been led by Piper Bill Millin. The British and French of No.4 Commando had separate targets in Ouistreham: the French, a blockhouse and the Casino; the British two German batteries which overlooked the beach. The blockhouse proved too strong for the Commandos' PIAT (Projector Infantry Anti Tank) weapons, but the Casino was taken with the aid of a Centaur tank. The British Commandos achieved both battery objectives only to find the gun mounts empty and the guns removed. Leaving the mopping-up procedure to the infantry, the Commandos withdrew from Ouistreham to join the other units of their brigade (Nos.3, 6 and 45), moving inland to join-up with the 6th Airborne Division.
[edit] Juno Beach
Main article: Juno Beach
Canadian operations on D-Day

The Canadian forces that landed on Juno Beach faced 2 heavy batteries of 155 mm guns and 9 medium batteries of 75 mm guns, as well as machine-gun nests, pillboxes, other concrete fortifications, and a seawall twice the height of the one at Omaha Beach. The first wave suffered 50% casualties, the second highest of the five D-Day beachheads. The use of armour was successful at Juno, in some instances actually landing ahead of the infantry as intended and helping clear a path inland.[27]
Personnel of Royal Canadian Navy Beach Commando "W" landing on Mike Beach, Juno sector of the Normandy beachhead. 6 June 1944.

Despite the obstacles, the Canadians were off the beach within hours and beginning their advance inland. A single troop of four tanks managed to reach the final objective phase line, but hastily retreated, having outrun its infantry support. In particular, two fortified positions at the Douvres Radar Station remained in German hands (and would for several days until captured by British commandos), and no link had been established with Sword Beach.

By the end of D-Day, 30,000 Canadians had been successfully landed, and the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division had penetrated further into France than any other Allied force, despite having faced strong resistance at the water's edge and later counterattacks on the beachhead by elements of the German 21st and 12th SS Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) Panzer divisions on 7 June and 8 June.
[edit] Gold Beach
Main article: Gold Beach

At Gold Beach,25,000 men were landed, under the command of Lieutenant-General Miles Dempsey Commander of the British 2nd Army. The casualties were also quite heavy, around 400, partly because bad weather also the swimming Sherman DD tanks were delayed, and the Germans had strongly fortified a village on the beach. However, the 50th (Northumbrian) Infantry Division overcame these difficulties and advanced almost to the outskirts of Bayeux by the end of the day. With the exception of the Canadians at Juno Beach, no division came closer to its objectives than the 50th.

No.47 (RM) Commando was the last British Commando unit to land and came ashore on Gold east of La Hamel. Their task was to proceed inland then turn right (west) and make a 16-kilometre (10 mi) march through enemy territory to attack the coastal harbour of Port en Bessin from the rear. This small port, on the British extreme right, was well sheltered in the chalk cliffs and significant in that it was to be a prime early harbour for supplies to be brought in including fuel by underwater pipe from tankers moored offshore.
[edit] Omaha Beach
Main article: Omaha Beach
Survivors of a sunken troop transport wade ashore on Omaha Beach

Elements of the 1st Infantry Division and 29th Infantry Division (US) faced the recently formed German 352nd Infantry Division, a mixed group of Russian "volunteers" and teenagers stiffened with a cadre of east front veterans, unusual in the fact that it was one of the few German divisions remaining with a full complement of three regiments albeit at reduced strength; fifty percent of its officers had no combat experience. However, Allied intelligence was unaware until two weeks before the planned invasion that the 100 km stretch of beach originally allocated to be defended by the 716th Infantry Division (static) had been cut into two parts in March, with the 716th moving to the "Caen Zone", and the 352nd taking over the "Bayeux Zone", thus doubling the complement of defenders.[28] Omaha was also the most heavily fortified beach, with high bluffs defended by funneled mortars, machine guns, and artillery, and the pre-landing aerial and naval bombardment of the bunkers proved to be ineffective. Difficulties in navigation caused the majority of landings to drift eastwards, missing their assigned sectors and the initial assault waves of tanks, infantry and engineers took heavy casualties. Of the 16 tanks that landed upon the shores of Omaha Beach only 2 survived the landing. The official record stated that "within 10 minutes of the ramps being lowered, [the leading] company had become inert, leaderless and almost incapable of action. Every officer and sergeant had been killed or wounded [...] It had become a struggle for survival and rescue".

Only a few gaps were blown in the beach obstacles, resulting in problems for subsequent landings. The heavily defended draws, the only vehicular routes off the beach, could not be taken and two hours after the first assault the beach was closed for all but infantry landings. Commanders (including General Omar Bradley) considered abandoning the beachhead, but small units of infantry, often forming ad hoc groups, supported by naval artillery and the surviving tanks, eventually infiltrated the coastal defences by scaling the bluffs between strongpoints. Further infantry landings were able to exploit the initial penetrations and by the end of the day two isolated footholds had been established. American casualties at Omaha on D-Day numbered around 5,000 out of 50,000 men, most in the first few hours, while the Germans suffered 1,200 killed, wounded or missing. The tenuous beachhead was expanded over the following days, and the original D-Day objectives were accomplished by D+3.
[edit] Pointe du Hoc
Main article: Pointe du Hoc

The massive concrete cliff-top gun emplacement at Pointe du Hoc was the target of the 2nd Ranger Battalion, commanded by James Earl Rudder. The task was to scale the 30 meter (100 ft) cliffs under the cover of night, approximately at 5:30, one hour prior to the landings with ropes and ladders, and then attack and destroy the German coastal defence guns, which were thought to command the Omaha and Utah landing areas. The infantry commanders did not know that the guns had been moved prior to the attack, and they had to press farther inland to find them and eventually destroyed them. However, fortifications themselves were still vital targets since a single artillery forward observer based there could have called down accurate fire on the U.S. beaches. The Rangers were eventually successful, and captured the fortifications. They then had to fight for two days to hold the location, losing more than 60% of their men. Afterwards they regrouped and continued Northeast to the rally point one mile from the gun emplacements on Pointe Du Hoc.
[edit] Utah Beach
Main article: Utah Beach
Landing craft approach the beach as smoke on the shore emanates from German positions.

Casualties on Utah Beach, the westernmost landing zone, were the lightest of any beach, with 197 out of the roughly 23,000 troops that landed. The 4th Infantry Division troops landing at Utah Beach found themselves in the wrong positions because of a current that pushed their landing craft to the southeast. Instead of landing at Tare Green and Uncle Red sectors, they came ashore at Victor sector, which was lightly defended, and as a result, relatively little German opposition was encountered. The 4th Infantry Division was able to press inland relatively easily over beach exits that had been seized from the inland side by the 502nd and 506th Parachute Infantry Regiments of the 101st Airborne Division. This was partially by accident, because their planned landing was further down the beach (Brig. Gen. Theodore Roosevelt Jr, the Asst. Commander of 4th Division, upon discovering the landings were off course, was famous for stating "We will start the war from right here."). By early afternoon, the 4th Infantry Division had succeeded in linking up with elements of the 101st. American casualties were light, and the troops were able to press inward much faster than expected, making it a near-complete success.
[edit] War memorials and tourism
The Bény-sur-Mer Canadian War Cemetery.
The German War cemetery in La Cambe

The beaches at Normandy are still referred to on maps and signposts by their invasion codenames. There are several vast cemeteries in the area. The American cemetery, in Colleville-sur-Mer, contains row upon row of identical white crosses and Stars of David, immaculately kept, commemorating the American dead. Commonwealth graves, in many locations, use white headstones engraved with the person's religious symbol and their unit insignia. The largest cemetery in Normandy is the La Cambe German war cemetery, which features granite stones almost flush with the ground and groups of low-set crosses. There is also a Polish cemetery.

Streets near the beaches are still named after the units that fought there, and occasional markers commemorate notable incidents. At significant points, such as Pointe du Hoc and Pegasus Bridge, there are plaques, memorials or small museums. The Mulberry harbour still sits in the sea at Arromanches. In Sainte-Mère-Église, a dummy paratrooper hangs from the church spire. On Juno Beach, the Canadian government has built the Juno Beach Information Centre, commemorating one of the most significant events in Canadian military history. In Caen is a large Museum for Peace, which is dedicated to peace generally, rather than only to the battle

(Source Wikipedia)

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Dari Sun Tzu Ke Clausewitz


Dua Legenda Perang dari Abad yang sangat jauh berbeda, Sun Tzu menyatakan dalam beberapa rumusan strategi-nya yang sederhana dalam melaksanakan suatu Operasi Militer yang telah banyak digunakan secara umum.  Salah satu diantaranya “Jika anda mengetahui kekuatan lawan dan tahu kekuatan sendiri, anda tidak perlu takut akan hasil dari ratusan pertempuran”. Sementara Clausewitz mengatakan “Strategi bertahan lebih kuat daripada menyerang”.  

Apakah kedua pernyataan strategi tersebut masih akurat atau terlalu sederhana. Apa pelajaran yang dapat dipelajari dari kedua pemikir strategi tersebut, khususnya bagi mereka yang memusatkan perhatiannya dalam merancang konsep operasi di laut, udara dan di ruang angkasa, dan mereka-mereka yang merancang operasi di wilayah daratan, seperti  operasi di hutan, gurun pasir, di perkotaan/perkampungan dan di pegunungan.     Bagaimana sebaiknya kita mengharapkan perkembangan strategi tersebut dapat diterjemahkan pada kondisi maraknya pertumbuhan kota-kota besar (Mega City) dimasa yang akan datang.  Selain itu ada strategi yang “menyatakan menyerang pada pusat kekuatan lawan” (direct attack to enemy center of gravity) yang disebut-sebut sebagai Brain Warfare (perang otak).   Sedangkan Sun Tzu dalam satu rumusan strategi-nya “Musuh tidak perlu harus dihancurkan dengan kekuatan bersenjata”.    Pertanyaannya apakah kedua strategi tersebut tidak saling bertentangan?    Masih banyak lagi rumusan-rumusan strategi dari berbagai pemikir lainnya seperti B.H. Liddell Hart, Arthur F. Lykke Jr, Michael Howard, Napoleon, Mahan, Giulio Douhet, Mao Tse-Tung, Jomini, Mitchell, Andre Beaufre dan pemikir-pemikir strategi lainnya.Selanjutnya sejalan dengan pergeseran paradigma mengenai perang, negara-negara maju telah merumuskan aktivitas perang pada beberapa strata yang saling terkait, yang terbentuk dalam suatu hierarkis.    Strata tersebut adalah Strata Grand Strategis, Strata Strategi, Strata Operasional dan Strata Taktik yang secara universal disebut sebagai Strata Perang (The Level of War).    Masing-masing strata tersebut memiliki rumusan strategi yang berbeda dalam menentukan sasaran yang ingin dicapai, konsep/cara yang akan disusun serta sarana kekuatan yang akan digunakan.  Yang juga perlu menjadi perhatian kita bersama bagaimana melihat perkembangan strategi yang sesuai dengan revolusi perang saat ini dan dimasa yang akan datang.    Serta yang paling penting adalah bagaimana kita merumuskan konsep strategi operasional mempunyai arti dan berguna (analog) dengan kehidupan masyarakat.    Hal ini merupakan suatu pertimbangan bagi pejabat pengambil keputusan dan staf perencana dalam merumuskan strategi, mana yang lebih utama: Apakah melaksanakan operasi sebanyak mungkin atau bagaimana operasi dilaksanakan secepat mungkin. Demikian pula sehubungan dengan terjadinya pergeseran paradigma rentang operasi militer yaitu operasi militer untuk perang dan operasi militer selain perang maka para perancang operasi perlu memikirkan bagaimana strategi diterjemahkan ke dalam konsep rencana operasi baik untuk operasi militer dalam perang dan operasi militer selain perang saat ini dan dimasa yang akan datang, dapat berguna dan bermanfaat bagi keamanan nasional.  Essay Sun Tzu tentang “Seni Berperang” merupakan risalah paling awal yang pernah diketahui tentang hal ini, tetapi belum pernah diunggulkan secara pengertian yang mendalam dan komprehensif.     Hal ini akan lebih baik bila disebut intisari hakekat kebijaksanaan dalam berperang.     Diantara seluruh pemikir militer dimasa lalu, hanya Clausewitz yang sebanding atau dapat dipersamakan dengan seni berperang Sun Tzu, bahkan ia lebih aktual dibanding Sun Tzu.   Walaupun Clausewitz menulis lebih dari dua ribu tahun kemudian setelah Sun Tzu.    Sun Tzu memiliki visi yang lebih jelas, wawasan yang lebih menyeluruh, dan selalu segar walaupun sebagian masih kuno.    Karena perhatian Sun Tzu diarahkan pada dasar-dasar dan prinsip-prinsip perang.   Pemikirannya masih tetap relevan hingga saat ini, walau ditulis pada tahun 500 SM, berikut hasil observasinya pada topik-topik terkini. Bagi Sun Tzu  pada pelajaran perang (on the study of war) maka Perang adalah suatu masalah yang sangat penting bagi suatu negara.  Perang menyangkut masalah hidup atau mati.  Perang adalah suatu jalan untuk mampu bertahan atau hancur. dan  Perang merupakan perintah yang harus dipelajari secara keseluruhan”.

Ada lima hal yang harus dipertimbangkan dalam mempelajari peperangan yaitu: pertama   Alasan moral.   Alasan moral memudahkan rakyat dan pemerintah untuk memiliki keyakinan bersama, mengapa kita berperang? Sehingga rakyatpun mau bekerjasama dengan pemerintah dalam suka dan duka, bahkan mengorbankan nyawa sekalipun, kedua  Alasan alam.    Alam menyangkut cuaca, iklim dan sebagainya, seperti perubahan iklim dan keterbatasan waktu. ketiga   Alasan situasi.    Situasi menyangkut jarak, sifat alami suatu daerah dan apakah kondisi fisiknya memungkinkannya selamat dari kematian.  keempat alasan kepemimpinan.   Kepemimpinan mengacu pada kualitas yang harus dimiliki komandan dalam memimpin, yang mencakup kebijaksanaan, kepercayaan diri, belas kasihan, keberanian dan keteguhan serta lainnya dan kelima.    Alasan disiplin.   Kepemimpinan mencakup sistem imbalan dan ancaman hukuman, logistik dan sebagainya. Kelima hal yang mendasar ini harus dimengerti sepenuhnya oleh setiap komandan.    Mereka yang mengerti kelima hal mendasar tersebut akan selalu menang dan mereka yang tidak mengerti pasti akan dikalahkan. “Dalam seni praktis perang, hal terbaik dari semua adalah untuk mendapatkan musuh negara secara utuh dan lengkap; untuk memusnahkan dan menghancurkan bukanlah hal yang sangat baik.    Oleh karena itu pula, lebih baik menangkap seluruh angkatan darat, daripada menghancurkannya, menangkap satu Resimen, satu Detasemen atau seluruh kompi daripada memusnahkannya.    Selanjutnya, berperang dan menaklukan dalam seluruh peperangan anda bukanlah suatu hal yang cemerlang; kecemerlangan terdiri dari mematahkan pertahanan musuh tanpa berperang”.  


“Melihat kemenangan hanya pada saat dalam pengetahuan yang biasabukanlah puncak kecemerlangan.   Bukan pula puncak kecemerlanganjika anda berperang dan menaklukan dan kemudian seluruh kerajaanmenyambut, "good job" “Untuk mengangkat sehelai rambut pada musimgugur bukanlah suatu tanda dari kekuatan yang besar; untuk melihat mentaridan bulan bukanlah tanda dari ketajaman penglihatan; untuk mendengarsuara halilintar bukanlah tanda pendengaran yang taaajam.    Apa yang disebut para leluhur kita dengan perang yang lebih pintar adalah perang yang tidak hanya menang, tetapi mengatasi kemenangan dengan tenang”.

“Selanjutnya, kemenangan tersebut tidak memberikannya reputasi akan kebijaksanaan atau hormat karena keberaniannya.    Ia memenangkan peperangannya dengan tidak membuat kesalahan.    Tidak membuat kesalahan adalah hal yang membangun suatu kepastian akan kemenangan, yang berarti menaklukan musuh yang sudah dikalahkan”. “Maka, ini adalah perang dimana strategi kemenangan akan pada perang setelah kemenangan didapatkan, dimana ia ditakdirkan untuk mengalahkan perang pertama dan kemudian mencari kemenangan”.

 “Merupakan aturan dalam perang, jika kekuatan kita sepuluh pada yang musuhmemiliki satu kekuatan, maka kita mengepungnya; jika lima dengan satu, maka kita menyerangnya; jika dua kali lipatnya,  “Jika kekuatannya sama, kita dapat menawarkan perang; jika sedikit kurang dalam jumlah, kita dapat menghindari musuh; jika cukup tidak seimbang dalam berbagai hal, kita dapat lari.    Selanjutnya, walaupun perang yang terus menerus dapat dilakukan dengan kekuatan yang sangat kecil, pada akhirnya dapat ditangkap oleh kekuatan yang lebih besar”

 Hakekat kemenangan intinya Ia akan menang jika mengetahui kapan saatnya berperang dan kapan saatnya tidak   Ia akan menang jika mengetahui bagaimana memanfaatkan kekuatan pasukan, baik besar maupun kecil..         Ia akan menang jika memiliki angkatan perang yang dijiwai oleh semangat yang sama pada seluruh tingkatan.  Ia akan menang jika mempersiapkan dirinya sendiri dan menunggu saat musuh tidak siap.    Ia akan menang jika ia memiliki kapasitas militer dan tidak diganggu oleh masalah kedaulatan.
“Ada pepatah: “Jika anda mengenal musuh dan diri anda sendiri, maka tidak perlu takut pada hasil dari ratusan peperangan.   Jika anda mengenal diri sendiri tetapi tidak mengenal musuh, maka untuk setiap kemenangan yang diraih anda juga akan menderita kekalahan".   Jika anda tidak mengenal musuh dan anda sendiri, maka anda akan kalah pada setiap peperangan”. On conduct of war maka  Seni perang mengajarkan kita untuk tidak mengandalkan pada kemungkinan musuh tidak datang, tetapi pada kesiapsiagaan kita menyambut   mereka; tidak mengandalkan pada kemungkinan mereka tidak menyerang, tetapi lebih pada kenyataan bahwa kita telah membuat posisi yang tidak dapat diserang”  Pada pengelabuan (on deception). “Semua peperangan berdasarkan pada tipu muslihat.   Maka, jika dapat menyerang, kita harus terlihat seperti tidak mampu menyerang; saat kita menggunakan kekuatan kita, maka harus terlihat tidak aktif; saat kita dekat, kita harus membuat musuh percaya bahwa kita jauh; saat kita jauh, kita harus membuat mereka percaya kita dekat.    Tahan umpan untuk menarik musuh.    Buat kerusuhan palsu, dan hancurkan mereka”. Jika ia aman dalam segala hal, maka bersiaplah menghadapinya.   Jika ia unggul dalam kekuatan, maka hindari.    Jika lawan anda bertemperamen choleric, cari cara untuk melukainya.   Berpura-pura lemah, hingga ia menjadi arogan”  “Jika ia sedang bersenang-senang, jangan beri kesempatan beristirahat.   Jika kekuatannya bersatu, pecahbelahkan.    Serang dia saat ia tidak siap, muncullah disaat anda tidak diperkirakan.    Semua akal daya militer ini, yang membawa kepada kemenangan, janganlah sampai diketahui sebelumnya.   Pada metode penyerangan (on methods of attack). “Dalam peperangan, tidak ada lebih dari dua metode penyerangan – langsung dan tidak langsung; maka kombinasi dari kedua hal ini memunculkan satu rangkaian manuver yang tiada akhir.    Baik langsung dan tidak langsung akan ada secara bergantian.   Seperti bergerak dalam satu lingkaran – anda tidak akan pernah mencapai akhir.    Siapa yang akan lelah dengan kemungkinan kombinasinya?”.     Pada bermanuver (on manouvering). “Jangan menelan umpan yang ditawarkan musuh.  Jangan mengganggu pasukan yang sedang pulang ke rumah.   Saat anda mengepung suatu pasukan, berikan tempat bagi mereka.   Jangan menekan musuh yang prustasi terlalu keras”. On long wars  “Jika anda terlibat dalam perang yang sesungguhnya, jika kemenangan lama datang, maka senjata akan rusak dan semangat mereka akan berkurang.   Sekali lagi, jika perang diperpanjang, sumber daya negara akan tidak seimbang dengan yang diderita.   Maka, walaupun kita telah mendengar tentang ketergesaan yang bodoh dalam perang, kepintaran tidak pernah dihubungkan dengan penundaan yang lama.    Tidak ada contoh dimana suatu negara mendapat manfaat dari perang yang diperpanjang”. 

Simak lima dosa yang tidak boleh terjadi pada seorang Jenderal (on the five sins of a general) yang berbahaya yang dapat mempengaruhi dan membawa kehancuran pada pelaksanaan perang”.   Kecerobohan, yang akan membawa ke kehancuran.  Pengecut, yang akan membuat kita ditangkap.     Sifat gegabah yang dapat diprovokasi oleh hinaan. Haus rasa hormat yang sensitif pada rasa malu. Terlalu khawatir pada anak buahnya, yang membuat dia cemas dan bermasalah.  Sebaliknya “Seorang Jenderal yang maju tanpa memikirkan ketenaran dan yang mundur tanpa takut tercemar, yang hanya berfikir untuk melindungi negaranya dan bertugas dengan baik untuk kedaulatannya, adalah perhiasan bagi suatu kerajaan”.

Mengenal lawan dan diri sendiri . Aku tahu kemampuanku, aku pun tahu kelemahan musuhku, dengan mengetahui dirimu sendiri dan mengetahui musuhmu, seseorang akan mampu memasuki ajang peperangan tanpa ancaman bahaya. Aku tak kenal musuhku, tetapi aku tahu persis kekuatanku, dengan mengetahui kekuatan sendiri tanpa mengetahui kekuatan dan kelemahan lawan, kesempatan memperoleh kemenangan hanya separuhnya. ku tak kenal musuhku, aku pun tak tahu kekuatanku, kamu pasti kalah, berperang tanpa mengetahui keadaan musuh, juga tanpa mengetahui keadaan sendiri, tentu kalah. Jadi “jika anda mengetahui kekuatan lawan dan tahu kekuatan sendiri, anda tidak perlu takut akan hasil dari ratusan pertempuran”   Rencana perang yang paling baik adalah menang melalui strategi dengan menggunakan akalmu untuk mengalahkan musuh.  Mengalihkan keinginan musuhmu melalui seni berdiplomasi.   Menaklukan dengan kekerasan.

 Strategi yang baik tidak pernah ada aturan yang ketat dan kaku.   Strategi yang baik haruslah meniru air yang selalu berubah sesuai tempatnya.   Tak ada pula rumusan untuk melakukan  manuver yang baik Hindarilah musuh yang kuat dan seranglah yang lemah.   Bersiaplah mengubah strategi sesuai dengan perubahan pihak musuh.   Strategi yang baik adalah lebih dahulu mencapai garis depan agar dapat menempati posisi yang menguntungkan untuk menghancurkan lawan.Perencanaan yang cermat akan menghasilkan kemenangan.  Perencanaan yang buruk akan membuahkan kekalahan.   Apalagi sama sekali tanpa perencanaan. Sebelum perang pecah, timbanglah kekuatan dan kelemahan pasukanmu sendiri dan pasukan musuhmu. Artinya berperanglah dengan dirimu sebelum engkau berdamai dengan orang lain.